Cash + Points: When Are They the Best Redemption?

Cash + Points: When Are They the Best Redemption?

While Delta’s recent announcements of their sweeping award program changes have caused an uproar among frequent flyers, one of the areas most likely to trip up leisure travelers are the airline’s new cash plus points awards.

On the surface, it looks like there are two types of cash plus points redemptions:

  • hotel nights
  • flights

But the reality is, the two main types of cash plus points redemptions are:

  • ones that are worth it
  • ones that rip you off

Deltas fall into the latter category one of the reasons frequent flyers are in such a stink about the changes but lets dig a little deeper.

When Should You Use Cash Plus Points

BA-Avios

Like my favorite trick for when I don’t quite have enough points with the Chase Ultimate Rewards, that allows you to take advantage of award ticket pricing even when you don’t have points, cash plus points rates are great for those moments when a full fare ticket is way more than you’re willing to pay.

There’s relatively uncharted territory with airlines, especially domestic carriers, which is why Delta’s announcement was big news.

British Airways has offered an Avios & Money option for some time that actually give you a set of options between full points price and half points price of different ways you can pay a mix of cash and points:

You end up paying between 1.4 and 1.1 cents per mile, which is not bad, and a respectable rate for redeeming miles for flights in the first place.

Redeem your Starpoints
Redeem your Starpoints

Hotels have been successfully offering cash plus points rates for much longer in part because they seem happy to offer cash plus points rates that actually make clear sense for consumers.

Starwood, which uses membership rewards points that can be redeemed for anywhere from 1.25 cents per mile for flights to 2.3 cents per mile for rooms, values its points between 1.5 and 2 cents per point in its cash plus points options:

Interestingly, the middle of the chart, Category 4 hotels one of the most frequently booked have the lowest redemption rate. The rate is 1.8 cents per points at high end hotels.

Cash Plus Points Redemptions to Avoid

As I mentioned earlier, the new Delta cash plus points fall into the category of cash plus points awards you’re better off avoiding, and here’s why.

When redeeming air travel awards, you always want to aim to get a value of at least 1 cent per mile in relation to the true ticket price, or you’re better off paying cash.

For instance, 25,000 miles to fly domestically on a flight that’s ticketing for $526 is a great deal (2.1 cents per mile), while 60,000 miles to fly to Europe when flights are ticketing at $413 which is, admittedly, pretty hard to find these days is not (6.8 cents per mile).

Delta's award booking options
Delta’s award booking options

With the Delta awards, though, things are a little trickier. It might look like you are getting a decent value for your miles compared to the cash price of a flight, but you’re getting a bad rate compared to how Delta typically values miles.

Looking at this, it seems like paying $159 instead of 10,000 points (1.5 cents per mile) is not that bad of a deal if the full price is usually 35,000, BUT the problem is, that’s not usually the miles price. Its 25,000. So you’re better off looking for a different flight in the lowest category. You can save $159 per person for a few more minutes of work.

The morale of the story?

Cash plus points awards can be great to help in a pinch or even serve as a way to essentially buy additional points when you need them at an advantageous rate.

But not always. Price out the cents per point value of any cash plus points fare against both standard cash fares and full points fares before you book to make sure its a good deal.

Best Travel Credit Cards
Best Travel Credit Cards Best Travel Credit Cards Best Travel Credit Cards Best Travel Credit Cards Best Travel Credit Cards